The Absolute Best Pina Colada in Chicago [Updated 2024]

Over the years, I’ve had the pleasure of sampling a variety of pina coladas from numerous bars and restaurants across the city.

After reviewing 12 distinct offerings, I've uncovered some hidden gems that truly elevate this classic tropical cocktail.

From traditional recipes to creative twists, each location has its own unique take that deserves recognition.

Join me as I share my top picks for the best pina colada experiences in Chicago, perfect for warm summer days or any time you need a little getaway.

Moneygun

Highlights
Cozy "hole in the wall" vibe
Inspiring cocktail options
Great for chill nights
Perfectly mixed drinks
Friendly, bustling atmosphere

Moneygun is quite the hidden gem nestled in the heart of Chicago, and my recent visit had me diving headfirst into a world of cocktail revelry. As soon as I walked in, the charming “hole in the wall” vibe enveloped me, immediately inviting a sense of warmth and intimacy. The atmosphere buzzed with friendly chatter, making it the perfect backdrop for a relaxed evening.

Now, let’s talk about the piña colada—oh, what a delight it was! The perfectly mixed drink transported me straight to a tropical paradise. Each sip revealed a symphony of flavors that danced effortlessly on my palate, featuring a balance of sweetness and a hint of coconut bliss. You can tell the bartenders take their craft seriously, as they’ve obviously mastered the art of crafting an exquisite cocktail.

What further adds to Moneygun's charm is the inspiring cocktail menu that had me dreaming of my next visit while I savored this creamy masterpiece. If you’re seeking a chill night with an exceptional piña colada, this is the spot to be!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Schaumburg.

La Mejikana

Highlights
Delicious Mexican Meals
Strong, Flavorful Drinks
Vibrant Atmosphere
Quick Seating and Service
Must-Try Coconut Margarita

Review of La Mejikana’s Pina Colada

Nestled in the heart of Chicago, La Mejikana is a vibrant gem that truly knows how to whip up a delicious pina colada. As I settled into the lively atmosphere, indulging in the tantalizing aroma of authentic Mexican cuisine, I couldn't wait to taste what was in store. The drink arrived, a beautiful swirl of creamy coconut and perfectly blended rum, beckoning me to indulge.

Let me tell you, the flavor was nothing short of sensational. Each sip transported me straight to a tropical paradise. The balance of sweetness and the refreshing zesty notes left me utterly enchanted. It was distinctly strong, which I particularly appreciated — a quality that separates a great pina colada from merely a good one.

The service was swift and welcoming, adding to the overall delightful experience. Pairing the drink with a few flavorful bites from their menu enhanced my journey even further. If you're in the mood for a pina colada that packs a punch while also indulging your taste buds, La Mejikana definitely deserves a spot on your must-try list. This colorful venue promises not just a drink, but a joyful escape!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Oak Park.

The Pink Squirrel

Highlights
Fun atmosphere
Creative drinks
Boozy milkshakes
Ferris wheel of drinks
Great presentation

First off, the atmosphere at The Pink Squirrel is undeniably fun. With its retro decor and neon signs, it's impossible not to feel a little nostalgic for simpler times. But don't let the throwback vibe fool you; their drinks are anything but outdated.

Their pina colada was one of the most creative I've ever tasted. It had all the classic ingredients: rum, coconut cream, and pineapple juice. But what really set it apart was the addition of fresh mint leaves and a splash of lime juice which gave it a zesty kick that balanced out the sweetness perfectly.

But if you're feeling adventurous (or just in need of a boozy dessert), I highly recommend trying one of their boozy milkshakes. They have flavors ranging from chocolate peanut butter to fruity pebbles, all with a generous pour of alcohol mixed in.

One thing that really impressed me about The Pink Squirrel was their presentation. Every drink came with an Instagram-worthy garnish or unique glassware that added to the overall experience. And if you're feeling extra festive, they even have a "Ferris wheel" of drinks that can be shared among friends.

Overall, The Pink Squirrel is definitely worth checking out if you're on the hunt for the best pina colada in Chicago (or any other creative cocktail). Their playful yet professional approach to mixology makes for an unforgettable drinking experience.

You might also want to check out the best bars in Naperville.

Cindy's Rooftop

Highlights
Amazing views
Great atmosphere
Unique viewpoint
Comfy seating
Fantastic service

First of all, let me start by saying that the views from Cindy's Rooftop are absolutely amazing! There's nothing quite like sipping on a delicious pina colada while overlooking the beautiful cityscape of Chicago. The atmosphere is also top-notch, with a unique viewpoint that makes you feel like you're on top of the world.

The seating at Cindy's Rooftop is incredibly comfortable, which is important when you plan to spend some time enjoying their fantastic cocktails. And speaking of cocktails, their pina colada definitely did not disappoint! The blend of pineapple and coconut was perfectly balanced and complemented by just the right amount of rum.

But what really sets Cindy's Rooftop apart is their fantastic service. From the moment I walked in, I felt welcomed and taken care of. The staff was knowledgeable about the cocktails they were serving and made great recommendations based on my preferences.

Overall, if you're looking for an unforgettable experience with a great pina colada in Chicago, Cindy's Rooftop should be at the top of your list. It has everything you need for a perfect night out – amazing views, great atmosphere, comfy seating, unique viewpoint and fantastic service!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Joliet.

90 Miles Cuban Cafe

Highlights
Tasty food
Affordable
Great atmosphere
Friendly staff

First of all, I was blown away by the great atmosphere. From the moment I walked in, I felt like I was transported to Cuba with the colorful decor and lively music. The place was buzzing with diners enjoying their meals and drinks.

Speaking of drinks, let's talk about the pina colada. It was absolutely delicious! The balance between pineapple and coconut flavors was perfect, and it wasn't too sweet or watery like some pina coladas can be. Plus, the presentation was on point with a cute little umbrella and slice of pineapple on top.

But what really stood out to me about 90 Miles Cuban Cafe was the friendly staff. They were knowledgeable about the menu items and even gave me some recommendations on what to order next time I visit. And speaking of menu items, everything we ordered was tasty and affordable, so you won't break the bank while indulging in some tasty Cuban cuisine.

Overall, if you're looking for a great place to enjoy a delicious pina colada in Chicago, do yourself a favor and check out 90 Miles Cuban Cafe - you won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Evanston.

La Pulqueria ( Pilsen )

Highlights
Delicious food
Authentic Mexican
Excellent service
Unique pulque drinks

Upon arrival, I was greeted with a warm welcome and immediately felt at home. As I perused the menu, I noticed they had an impressive selection of pulque drinks, which are fermented Mexican beverages made from the sap of the maguey plant. Of course, being on a quest for the best pina colada in Chicago, I had to try theirs.

Let me tell you, this pina colada did not disappoint! It was creamy, sweet and had just the right amount of rum to give it that extra kick. It was like sipping paradise in a glass.

But La Pulqueria is more than just amazing pina coladas - their authentic Mexican food is also worth raving about. From tacos al pastor to chilaquiles verdes, every dish was packed with flavor and made with fresh ingredients.

The service was excellent as well - our server was attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. Plus, the atmosphere of La Pulqueria truly makes you feel like you're in Mexico City rather than Chicago.

Overall, if you're looking for a unique and delicious pina colada experience in Chicago, look no further than La Pulqueria ( Pilsen ). With their authentic Mexican cuisine and excellent service, it's no wonder why they've become a local favorite.

You might also want to check out the best bars in Elmhurst.

Bar Sótano

Highlights
Hidden location
Happy hour deals
Great mezcal/tequila
Cocktail pairing option
Excellent value

Firstly, finding the entrance to Bar Sótano was like discovering a secret hideout. This hidden location added an element of excitement to my visit, and I couldn't wait to see what they had in store for me.

Upon entering, I was pleasantly surprised by their affordable happy hour deals on cocktails and small plates. But let's talk about the pina colada. The bartender recommended a mezcal and tequila-based version that was smooth and well-balanced. It had just the right amount of sweetness without being overly syrupy.

To top it off, there was even a cocktail pairing option with their delicious tacos. This pairing elevated my experience to another level and made me feel like a true connoisseur.

What impressed me most was the excellent value for such high-quality drinks and food. I left feeling satisfied not only with my pina colada but also with the entire experience.

Overall, Bar Sótano is a must-visit spot for anyone seeking an adventure in cocktails, mezcal or tequila, or even Mexican cuisine. With its hidden location, happy hour deals, excellent cocktail pairings, and outstanding value, this place has truly won my heart as one of the best places to enjoy a pina colada in Chicago!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Deerfield.

Tack Room

Highlights
Great food
Friendly staff
Delicious cocktails
Live music

From the moment I walked in, I was impressed by the friendly staff who welcomed me with open arms. The ambiance of the place was fantastic, with comfortable seating and a cozy atmosphere that made me feel right at home.

But let's get to the main point: the pina colada. The one served at Tack Room is simply amazing! It had the perfect blend of coconut and pineapple flavors and a hint of rum that gave it just the right kick. It was creamy and smooth, without being overly sweet - a true masterpiece!

I couldn't help but pair my drink with some food from their menu, which turned out to be another highlight of my experience at Tack Room. Their dishes are carefully crafted with fresh ingredients and bold flavors that will leave your taste buds dancing.

If you're looking for some entertainment while you sip on your pina colada, Tack Room has got you covered. They offer live music performances that will keep you entertained all night long.

Overall, I would highly recommend Tack Room for anyone looking for a delicious pina colada in Chicago. The combination of great food, friendly staff, delicious cocktails, and live music make it an experience worth having.

You might also want to check out the best bars in Aurora.

Encanto Agave Bar

Highlights
Passionate about Mezcal
Unique bottles of Mezcal
Educating customers about liquor processes
Hard to find imported bottles
Fun and engaging bartender

Firstly, I was impressed by the bartender's passion for Mezcal. They had a vast selection of unique bottles that I've never seen before. The best part? The bartender was more than happy to educate me on the liquor-making process and how it differs from tequila.

While I wasn't there specifically for Mezcal, it was refreshing to see a bar so dedicated to educating its customers on their offerings. This dedication extended to their pina colada as well. The bartender took their time crafting the perfect drink and even added a small twist to make it unique.

One thing worth noting is that Encanto Agave Bar has a hard-to-find imported bottle selection that would be great for anyone looking to expand their knowledge of different liquors.

Overall, my experience at Encanto Agave Bar was fun and engaging thanks to the bartender's personality and passion for their craft. If you're looking for a spot that not only has great drinks but also cares about the education behind them, this is definitely a place worth checking out!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Arlington Heights.

Bar Goa, an Indian Gastropub

Highlights
Comedy Night and live music
Unique cocktails and Indian food
Great ambience for a tropical vibe
Phenomenal service for an amazing experience

Upon entering the pub, I was immediately transported to a tropical paradise with its beautifully decorated space that oozed an island vibe. The menu offered unique cocktails that were a perfect blend of Indian flavors and American twists. My eyes were drawn to their pina colada which was served in an actual coconut shell - it looked almost too good to drink!

As I took my first sip, I could taste the sweet flavors of coconut and pineapple, blending perfectly with the rum. It was not too sweet nor too strong, just the right balance for a refreshing summer drink. The presentation itself was enough to make anyone feel like they're on vacation.

Aside from their drinks, Bar Goa also offers Indian cuisine that pairs well with their cocktail selection. I highly recommend trying their samosas and butter chicken – both dishes had authentic Indian spices that tickled my taste buds.

The service at this gastropub is phenomenal! The staff were friendly and attentive, making sure we had everything we needed for an amazing experience. On top of that, they have Comedy Nights and live music performances which makes it an ideal spot for a night out with friends or a date.

Overall, if you're looking for a place to enjoy great cocktails and delicious food while being transported to an island paradise, Bar Goa is definitely worth checking out!

You might also want to check out the best volleyball clubs in Chicago.

El Mariachi Tequila Bar & Grill

Highlights
Best margaritas
Delicious food
Phenomenal service
Great drink options
Fried ice cream

First of all, the atmosphere was lively and festive. I felt like I was on a mini vacation as soon as I walked in. But let's get to the important stuff - the pina colada. While it may not be their specialty drink, they still make a mean one. The smooth blend of coconut and pineapple with just the right amount of rum left me feeling like I had just taken a sip straight from a fresh pineapple on the beaches of Hawaii.

But that's not all, folks! El Mariachi also has amazing margaritas (yes, I know this is supposed to be about pina coladas but hear me out). The salted rim adds an extra zing to the already perfect blend of tequila and lime juice. And if you're hungry, their food menu will not disappoint either. From tacos to fajitas to their famous fried ice cream, everything tasted fresh and flavorful.

But what really made my experience at El Mariachi stand out was their phenomenal service. Our waiter was attentive but not overbearing, making sure our drinks were always full and our food arrived promptly.

Overall, while El Mariachi may not be known for their pina coladas specifically, they definitely have some other great drink options as well as delicious food and outstanding service. It's definitely worth checking out if you're in the area!

The Diver

Highlights
Ambience
Food quality
Service
Decor
Flavorful

Firstly, the ambience of The Diver was fantastic. It had a cozy and intimate atmosphere that made me feel like I was on vacation in Hawaii.

Secondly, the food quality was outstanding! I ordered some appetizers to go with my pina colada and they were all delicious. The flavors complemented each other perfectly.

Thirdly, the service at The Diver was exceptional. The staff were very friendly and attentive to my needs throughout the evening.

The decor was another highlight of The Diver. The nautical theme added an extra touch of charm that made it a unique experience.

Last but not least, the pina colada itself was beyond amazing! It was so flavorful, creamy, and had just the right amount of sweetness. I could taste the freshness of the coconut milk and pineapple juice used to make it.

Overall, if you're looking for a place to grab an outstanding pina colada in Chicago then you should definitely check out The Diver. Trust me; it won't disappoint!