Chicago's Best Muffaletta [Updated 2024]

I've tried my fair share, and let me tell you, there are some real winners out there. In fact, I reviewed 12 different versions of this classic sandwich to find the absolute best muffaletta in all of Chicago.

From traditional delis to trendy cafes, I scoured the city for the perfect combination of meat, cheese, olives, and bread. So grab a napkin and get ready to drool as I take you on a journey through the best muffalettas in all of Chicago.

Cafe L'Appetito

Highlights
Fresh deli meat
Friendly staff
Outdoor seating
Delicious baked goods

First of all, I was impressed with the freshness of their deli meat as it added an extra layer of flavor to the muffaletta. It was obvious that they only use high-quality ingredients.

The staff at Cafe L'Appetito were also incredibly friendly and welcoming. They made sure I had everything I needed and even offered some recommendations for their other delicious menu items.

I opted to enjoy my muffaletta in their charming outdoor seating area. The atmosphere was perfect for a sunny day and added to my overall experience.

While I was there, I couldn't resist trying some of their baked goods. Let me tell you, they did not disappoint! Their pastries were perfectly flaky and melt-in-your-mouth delicious.

Overall, Cafe L'Appetito is definitely a contender for the best muffaletta in Chicago. With fresh ingredients, friendly service, and delightful outdoor seating atmosphere, it's worth a visit. Plus, their baked goods are an added bonus that will satisfy any sweet tooth cravings.

You might also want to check out the best tamales in Aurora.

The Original Nottoli & Son

Highlights
Homemade charcuterie
Family-owned for generations
Meaty subs and dishes

Walking into the restaurant, I was immediately hit with the comforting aroma of homemade charcuterie. As a self-proclaimed meat enthusiast, I knew I was in for a treat.

The family-owned business has been passed down for generations and it's clear that they take pride in their work. The staff was incredibly friendly and knowledgeable about the menu. They recommended their signature muffaletta and, of course, I had to give it a try.

When it arrived at my table, I couldn't help but admire the heft of the sandwich. It was packed full of meats and veggies that were all fresh and flavorful. The bread was perfectly toasted, giving an optimal crunch with each bite.

As someone who has tried many muffalettas in Chicago, this one truly stood out for me. The balance between salty meats and tangy olive salad was spot on. Plus, the portions were generous enough to keep me full for hours.

Overall, if you're looking for a delicious and authentic muffaletta experience in Chicago, The Original Nottoli & Son should be at the top of your list. Don't let its unassuming exterior fool you – they serve up some seriously meaty subs and dishes that will satisfy any carnivore's cravings!

You might also want to check out the best thai food in Schaumburg.

Firenze: Italian Street Food

Highlights
Quality ingredients
Outstanding bread
Excellent customer service
Flavorful fillings

Firstly, I was blown away by the quality of the ingredients used in their muffalettas. As a foodie, I appreciate fresh and top-notch ingredients and Firenze did not disappoint.

But what really stood out to me was their outstanding bread. It had the perfect texture - crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. It complemented the flavorful fillings beautifully.

The customer service at Firenze is excellent. The staff was friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about their menu. They helped me choose the perfect muffaletta that suited my taste buds.

Now let's talk about flavor - wow! Their muffalettas were bursting with flavor in every bite. The combination of meats, cheese, olives, and vegetables created an explosion of flavors in my mouth that left me wanting more.

Overall, I highly recommend Firenze: Italian Street Food for anyone looking for a delicious muffaletta experience in Chicago. Their use of quality ingredients, outstanding bread, excellent customer service, and flavorful fillings make them stand out from the rest. Trust me; you won't regret visiting this place!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Naperville.

Al's #1 Italian Beef

Highlights
Friendly staff
Fast service
Generous portions
Juicy flavorful beef
Well cooked fries

First, I have to say that the staff was extremely friendly and welcoming. They made me feel right at home as soon as I walked in. Not only that, but the service was lightning-fast! I didn't have to wait long at all for my order.

Now let's talk about the main attraction: the muffaletta! Al's #1 Italian Beef is known for their juicy, flavorful beef and they did not disappoint. The meat was cooked to perfection with just the right amount of seasoning. The bread was also fresh and had a nice crunch to it.

But what really stood out to me were the generous portions. This sandwich was huge! I could barely finish half of it. And don't even get me started on their well-cooked fries - delicious!

Overall, I had a great experience at Al's #1 Italian Beef. If you're looking for a place with friendly staff, fast service, generous portions, and most importantly, an amazing muffaletta - this is it!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Schaumburg.

Baci Amore

Highlights
Amazing pizza
Friendly staff
Homemade bread
Delicious sandwiches

Let me start by saying that the pizza at Baci Amore is amazing! But, I'm not here to talk about pizza. I'm here for the muffaletta, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint.

First off, the staff was incredibly friendly. They greeted me with a smile and made sure I had everything I needed before diving into my sandwich. And let me tell you, the sandwich was worth waiting for.

The bread was homemade and had that perfect amount of crust on the outside while still being soft on the inside. The meats were sliced thin and piled high, making every bite a delicious adventure. The olive salad was tangy and flavorful without overpowering the other ingredients.

Overall, Baci Amore's muffaletta is definitely one of the best in Chicago. Don't let their amazing pizza distract you from trying one of their delicious sandwiches. You won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in Elgin.

Tempesta Market

Highlights
Quality sandwiches
Friendly staff
Varied Italian products

First off, let me just say that if you're looking for a delicious muffaletta, Tempesta Market can definitely satisfy your craving. The quality of their sandwiches is top-notch and I could taste the care put into each ingredient.

What really stood out to me was the friendliness of the staff. They were eager to help me choose my sandwich and even suggested some Italian products that caught my attention. Speaking of which, Tempesta Market has a great selection of varied Italian products that you won't find anywhere else in Chicago.

But back to the muffaletta - it was bursting with flavors! The olive spread was tangy yet savory, while the meats were expertly sliced and combined to create a perfect balance. And let's not forget about the bread - it was soft on the inside but crusty on the outside, making for a satisfying texture.

Overall, my experience at Tempesta Market was fantastic. If you're in search of an authentic muffaletta with a playful twist, look no further than this spot.

You might also want to check out the best steak in Schaumburg.

J.P. Graziano Grocery

Highlights
Family owned
High quality
Great portions
Exceptional service
Fresh ingredients

First of all, let me tell you that this family-owned grocery store knows how to make a high-quality muffaletta. The portions are generous and the ingredients are incredibly fresh. I almost felt like I was transported to New Orleans with every bite.

What really impressed me though was the exceptional service. The staff was knowledgeable about their products and gave great recommendations on what to try. It's clear that they take pride in their work and want their customers to have the best experience possible.

One thing to note is that J.P. Graziano's Grocery is not a sit-down restaurant, so be prepared to take your muffaletta to-go or enjoy it at one of their outdoor tables on a nice day.

Overall, I highly recommend J.P. Graziano Grocery for anyone looking for an authentic and delicious muffaletta in Chicago. Trust me, it's worth the trip just for this sandwich!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Evanston.

Tony's Italian Deli & Subs

Highlights
Quality subs
Old-fashioned service
Affordable price
Italian goodies
Enjoyed by Italians

Walking into Tony's, I was hit with the aroma of fresh Italian goodies that made my stomach growl with hunger. As I approached the counter, I was greeted with old-fashioned service that made me feel like family.

Without hesitation, I ordered their famous muffaletta and eagerly awaited its arrival. When it finally came out, I was blown away by the quality of the sub. The bread was crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, and the meats and cheese were fresh and flavorful.

The best part? The price! At an affordable cost, I couldn't believe how much meat they packed into this sandwich. No skimping here!

After chatting with a few locals in line, they told me that Tony's is a favorite among Italians. And now I understand why! This muffaletta is no joke.

So if you're looking for a delicious muffaletta in Chicago, head over to Tony's Italian Deli & Subs. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Naperville.

Rosie's Sidekick Sandwich Shop

Highlights
Vegan options
Homemade bread
Italian ice
Trifecta sandwich
Great service

Firstly, let me start by saying that this sandwich shop is truly a hidden gem. The moment I walked in, I was greeted with the aroma of freshly baked bread which immediately made me hungry. What caught my attention was their vegan options which are hard to find in most sandwich shops.

I decided to try their infamous Trifecta sandwich which had all my favorite ingredients - ham, salami, mortadella and provolone cheese. The sandwich was so big that it could barely fit in my hands but as soon as I took the first bite, I knew why it was called the Trifecta - it was a winning combination! The homemade bread just added to the deliciousness of the sandwich.

Another highlight of Rosie's Sidekick Sandwich Shop is their Italian ice which is perfect for cooling down on a hot day. It was refreshing and definitely hit the spot after indulging in such a hearty sandwich.

The service at Rosie's Sidekick Sandwich Shop is also top-notch. The staff were friendly and welcoming, making me feel like a regular customer even though it was my first visit.

In conclusion, if you're looking for a great muffaletta or just a fantastic sandwich experience, Rosie's Sidekick Sandwich Shop should definitely be on your list. Don't forget to try their Trifecta and Italian ice!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Schaumburg.

Jason's Deli

Highlights
Excellent food and service
Spicy Piquillo Pepper Relish sauce
Best customer service
Reliable delivery with hot food
Enthusiastic to help with modifications

Firstly, let me start with the food. The muffaletta I had at Jason's Deli was beyond my expectations. It was stacked high with layers of meats and cheeses, and the bread was toasted to perfection. But what made this muffaletta stand out from others in Chicago is their spicy Piquillo Pepper Relish sauce which added a kick of flavor to every bite.

What impressed me even more than the food was the customer service. The staff at Jason's Deli went above and beyond to ensure that my experience was exceptional. They were enthusiastic about helping me make modifications to my order without any hesitation or annoyance.

I also appreciated the reliability of their delivery service. My muffaletta arrived hot and fresh, just as if I had ordered it in-store.

Overall, I highly recommend Jason's Deli for anyone craving an outstanding muffaletta in Chicago. Their excellent food and service make them one of the best options in town.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Schaumburg.

Bari Foods

Highlights
Best sandwiches in Chicago
Assortment of hard-to-find Italian items
Famous guests and visitors to store
Incredible Italian sausage from butcher shop
Huge assortment of olives and cheeses

First of all, let me say that Bari Foods is not your typical deli. Not only do they serve the best sandwiches in Chicago, but they also have an incredible assortment of hard-to-find Italian items. And when I say "incredible", I mean it. If you're looking for something specific, chances are they have it.

One of the things that struck me about Bari Foods was their clientele. This place has had some famous guests and visitors to store over the years, so you know you're in good company when you stop by. But enough about that - let's talk about the muffaletta.

The muffaletta at Bari Foods is a masterpiece. The bread is fresh and crusty, and the ingredients inside are perfectly balanced. The Italian sausage from their butcher shop alone could make a lesser sandwich great, but add in their huge assortment of olives and cheeses (I lost count after 10 types), and you've got yourself a meal fit for royalty.

Overall, if you're looking for a muffaletta that will knock your socks off (and maybe even your shoes), then look no further than Bari Foods in Chicago. Just be prepared to leave with a bag full of hard-to-find Italian goodies - trust me, you won't be able to resist.

Conte Di Savoia

Highlights
Best Italian subs
Homemade sausage
Hand-sliced meats
Authentic flavors

First of all, I must say that this place deserves a spot on the list of the best muffaletta places in Chicago. But let's talk about the sandwich itself. The muffaletta here is not just a sandwich, it's a work of art. The bread is crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, and it's generously filled with homemade sausage, hand-sliced meats, and authentic Italian flavors.

What sets Conte Di Savoia apart from other places is their attention to detail. Every ingredient is meticulously chosen and prepared to perfection. They use only the freshest ingredients, which makes every bite something to savor.

The atmosphere at Conte Di Savoia is cozy and inviting. It feels like you're walking into someone's home kitchen where they are preparing a meal just for you. And don't even get me started on their selection of Italian products!

Overall, if you're looking for a delicious muffaletta in Chicago, look no further than Conte Di Savoia. Trust me; your taste buds will thank you!