Best Pizza in Evanston: Our Expert Picks for 2025

Having indulged in countless slices, I've made it my mission to discover the hidden gems and classic favorites that define this vibrant city's pizza scene.

After reviewing 12 standout pizzerias, I'm excited to share my top picks, each offering a unique twist on this beloved dish.

From deep-dish delights to thin-crust masterpieces, Evanston boasts an array of options that cater to every palate.

Join me on this delicious journey as we explore the best of what Evanston's pizza landscape has to offer!

DeSalvo's Pizza

Highlights
Amazing pizza and sandwiches
Unique gluten-free options
Family-friendly atmosphere
Clean and inviting space
Local ingredients used

When I stepped into DeSalvo's Pizza, I was immediately struck by the inviting atmosphere—a perfect blend of family-friendly vibes and mouth-watering aromas. I dove into their menu, eager to explore their amazing selection of both pizza and sandwiches. One standout feature that caught my eye was their commitment to offering unique gluten-free options; a delightful surprise for those with dietary preferences!

The pizza I chose was an absolute triumph—crafted with locally sourced ingredients that not only enhance flavor but also support the local community. Each bite was a harmony of textures, with a crust that struck just the right balance between crispy and chewy, and toppings that danced delightfully on my palate.

What truly sets DeSalvo's apart is their clean and inviting space, making it a spot where you can relish each slice without a care in the world. Whether you're dining with family or just grabbing a slice to go, DeSalvo's offers a perfect escape into pizza paradise. If you're in Evanston, skip the ordinary and treat yourself to the extraordinary delights at DeSalvo's—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Schaumburg.

Cantuccio's

Highlights
Build-your-own pizza option
Perfect balance of crust texture
Delicious cheese and toppings
Great for thin crust pizza lovers
Tasty Kale Caesar salad

Cantuccio's in Evanston is a hidden gem that truly understands the art of pizza-making. As I stepped into this cozy spot, I was instantly captivated by the inviting aroma wafting through the air. The menu offers a fantastic build-your-own pizza option, which is a dream come true for those who like to customize their pies with their favorite toppings.

I decided to go for a thin crust, and let me tell you: it was a slice of heaven! The crust had the perfect balance of crunch and chewiness, elevating everything it surrounded. Topped with a heavenly blend of cheese, each bite was an explosion of flavor that kept me wanting more. If you’re a fan of great toppings, you’ll be delighted by the abundance and quality here.

But don’t overlook the Kale Caesar salad—it was a delightful companion to my meal, adding a fresher touch amidst all that cheesy goodness. Overall, my experience at Cantuccio's was not just about the pizza; it was about the joy of discovery. For a fun, flavor-packed pizza adventure, I heartily recommend paying them a visit. You won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best thai food in Schaumburg.

Union Squared Pizza - Detroit Style

Highlights
Excellent Detroit Style Pizza
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Craft Beer Selection
Welcoming Hidden Patio
Friendly and Attentive Staff

My first impression was the hidden patio which added an unexpected but welcoming touch to the overall ambiance. The staff greeted me with a warm smile and led me inside where I immediately noticed the craft beer selection, which is perfect for those who want to pair their pizza with a local brew.

I started off my meal with the Spinach Artichoke Dip which was creamy, flavorful and served with crispy bread pieces. It was a great appetizer that really set the tone for what was to come.

Now, onto the main event: the pizza! Let me tell you, this is some of the best Detroit Style Pizza I've had in Evanston. The crust was thick, yet airy and crispy on the edges. The sauce had just enough tanginess to balance out the cheese and toppings. Every bite was packed with flavor.

The highlight of my experience at Union Squared Pizza - Detroit Style was definitely the friendly and attentive staff who made sure everything went smoothly during my visit. They were knowledgeable about their menu and offered great recommendations.

Overall, if you're looking for excellent Detroit style pizza in Evanston, Union Squared Pizza should be at the top of your list!

You might also want to check out the best tamales in Aurora.

Union Pizzeria - Evanston SPACE

Highlights
Scallion pizza with mixed flavors
Bigger than expected Chopped Wedge
Tender and juicy chicken added
Consistently delicious food
Refreshing matcha cocktail

Firstly, the scallion pizza was an absolute delight! The mixed flavors of onion and cheese were a match made in heaven. I couldn't help but indulge myself in this savory dish.

Next up, the chopped wedge salad was surprisingly bigger than expected. It was filled with fresh greens and topped with crispy bacon bits. Adding tender and juicy chicken to it made it even more delicious.

What I appreciate about Union Pizzeria is that their food is consistently delicious. Every bite felt like a burst of flavor in my mouth. It's no wonder they have a loyal customer base.

To top off my meal, I ordered their refreshing matcha cocktail. It was a perfect blend of sweetness and bitterness that complemented the pizza perfectly.

Overall, Union Pizzeria - Evanston SPACE is definitely one of the best pizzerias in Evanston. Their unique flavors and quality ingredients set them apart from other pizza places in town. If you're looking for a fun night out with great food and drinks, this is the place to be!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Schaumburg.

Bake HomeMade Pizza Evanston

Highlights
Flavorful pizzas
Worth the wait
Great for cooking at home

First of all, let me just say that the pizzas here are absolutely flavorful! From the first bite, I knew I was in for a treat. The sauce had just the right amount of tanginess, and the crust was crispy on the outside but soft on the inside - perfection!

Now, I must warn you that this place can get busy, so be prepared to wait a bit. But trust me when I say that it's totally worth the wait. Besides, who doesn't love a good pizza enough to wait for it?

What's great about Bake HomeMade Pizza Evanston is that they also offer pre-made pizzas that you can take home and cook yourself. So if you're feeling too lazy to go out or just want to impress your friends with your cooking skills (wink wink), this is definitely a great option.

Overall, I think Bake HomeMade Pizza Evanston deserves a spot on my list of best pizzas in Evanston. The flavors are top-notch and their commitment to quality is evident in every bite. Give it a try and let me know what you think!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Naperville.

Trattoria D.O.C.

Highlights
Creative pizza
Authentic pasta
Grilled calamari
Consistently good food
Friendly service

Firstly, I was impressed by the creative pizza options on the menu. I decided to try their "Funghi" pizza which was topped with mushrooms, truffle oil and goat cheese. The combination of flavors was simply heavenly! The crust was thin, crispy and had just the right amount of char.

While Trattoria D.O.C. is known for their pizzas, I couldn't resist trying their pasta as well. As an Italian food connoisseur, I can confidently say that their pasta dishes are truly authentic and flavorful.

For appetizers, I ordered the grilled calamari which was cooked to perfection and seasoned with just the right amount of herbs.

One thing that stood out to me about Trattoria D.O.C. was how consistently good their food is. Every dish that came out of the kitchen looked and tasted amazing.

Lastly, the service at Trattoria D.O.C. is top-notch! The staff is friendly and attentive without being overbearing.

Overall, if you're looking for a place in Evanston with great pizza, pasta dishes and more, then Trattoria D.O.C. should definitely be on your list!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in Elgin.

Firehouse Grill

Highlights
Friendly staff
Clean interior
Delicious flavors
Reasonable price

First of all, I was greeted by a friendly and hospitable staff who made me feel welcome. The interior of the restaurant is well-maintained and immaculately clean which added to my dining experience.

Now, let's talk about the pizza itself. The flavors were absolutely delicious! I tried their classic Margherita pizza and it was cooked to perfection with just the right amount of sauce, cheese, and toppings. I also tried their BBQ chicken pizza which had a unique blend of sweet and savory flavors that were simply irresistible.

What's even better is that the prices are very reasonable compared to other restaurants in Evanston. It won't break your bank account but will still give you a satisfying meal.

Overall, Firehouse Grill has definitely earned its place on my list of the best pizzas in Evanston. With its friendly staff, clean interior, delicious flavors, and reasonable prices - it's hard not to love this place. So if you're ever around Evanston looking for a great pizza fix, don't hesitate to stop by Firehouse Grill!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Evanston.

Evanston - Lou Malnati's Pizzeria

Highlights
Deep dish gluten-free
Excellent service
Top-notch crust

Firstly, I was impressed by their deep dish gluten-free option. As a gluten-free eater, it's always a struggle to find delicious pizza that doesn't contain wheat. But Lou Malnati's Pizzeria nailed it! I could taste the authenticity of their ingredients without compromising on my dietary restrictions.

Another highlight of my visit was the excellent service provided by the staff. They were attentive, friendly and made me feel right at home. It's always nice to receive good customer service especially when you're hungry and eager to dig into your pizza.

Now let's talk about the most important aspect of any pizza - the crust! And let me tell you, Lou Malnati's Pizzeria had a top-notch crust. The crust was crispy on the outside and soft on the inside with just the right amount of chewiness. It was like biting into a cloud of cheesy goodness.

Overall, I would highly recommend Evanston - Lou Malnati's Pizzeria to anyone looking for a mouth-watering deep-dish experience in Evanston. Trust me, you won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best steak in Schaumburg.

Panino's Pizzeria - Evanston

Highlights
Hot and prompt delivery
Vegetarian options explained well
Delicious Chicago style pizza
Homemade gelato by the manager

First off, I have to say that their delivery was hot and prompt, which is always a plus. As someone who values their time and hunger equally, this made me happy.

Now, let's talk about the pizza. They serve a delicious Chicago-style pizza that is sure to satisfy any craving. The crust was crispy on the outside but still had a nice chewiness to it. The sauce was perfectly seasoned and the cheese was melted just right - not too stringy and not too hard.

What impressed me most though, were the vegetarian options explained in detail by the staff. As a vegetarian myself, I appreciated being able to make an informed decision about what I was eating. It makes all the difference when you can tell that people are passionate about what they do.

Finally, for dessert they offered homemade gelato made by the manager himself! And let me tell you - it was divine. Creamy and rich with just the right amount of sweetness.

Overall, Panino's Pizzeria - Evanston is definitely worth checking out if you're looking for some quality pizza in Evanston. Plus, their attention to detail and customer service will make you feel like a valued guest rather than just another customer on their list.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Naperville.

Sarpino's Pizzeria Evanston

Highlights
Excellent customer service
Affordable prices with great offers
High-quality and tasty pizza
Calming and relaxing ambiance

Firstly, I was delighted to experience the excellent customer service at Sarpino's Pizzeria Evanston. The staff greeted me with a warm smile and were very knowledgeable about their pizza options. They also offered great recommendations based on my preferences.

As a writer who is always conscious of my budget, I appreciated the affordable prices and great offers available at Sarpino's. Despite the reasonable prices, there was no compromise when it came to the taste of the pizza. In fact, I found that the pizzas were of high-quality and extremely tasty.

I had a hard time choosing which pizza to order as they had so many delicious options available. One that stood out for me was their BBQ Chicken Pizza - it had just the right amount of sweetness to balance out the savory flavors.

Lastly, I loved the calming and relaxing ambiance of this pizza shop which made my dining experience even more enjoyable. The atmosphere was perfect for enjoying a slice or two with friends or family.

Overall, Sarpino's Pizzeria Evanston is definitely one of my top picks for best pizzas in Evanston due to its fantastic customer service, affordable prices, high-quality and delicious pizzas, and calming ambiance.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Schaumburg.

Blaze Pizza

Highlights
Vegan options
Customizable
Friendly staff
Gluten-free options (assumed)
Variety of Drinks

First things first, let me tell you that Blaze Pizza offers an array of vegan options which is a great relief for all the vegans out there. I was really impressed with their concept of customizable pizza where you can choose your own toppings and sauces. This gives you a chance to create your perfect pizza without any compromises.

The staff at Blaze Pizza are incredibly friendly and accommodating. They helped me choose my toppings and suggested some combinations as well. I even witnessed them go out of their way to make sure that every customer had a delightful experience.

Another highlight for me was the availability of gluten-free options (I assumed) for people who have dietary restrictions. The variety of drinks offered here is also commendable, with everything from soda to beer.

Overall, Blaze Pizza is a great option for pizza lovers looking for something different and unique in Evanston. The staff's hospitality, coupled with the ability to customize your own pizza, makes this place stand out from others. I highly recommend giving this place a try if you're in town!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Schaumburg.

Giordano's

Highlights
Delicious pizza
Large dining area
Great value for price
Friendly service
Comfortable outdoor seating

Firstly, let me start by saying that the pizza served at Giordano's is nothing short of a masterpiece. The delicious and cheesy deep-dish pizza melted in my mouth with every bite, leaving me craving for more. The crust was crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, which added to the overall texture of the pizza.

The dining area is large, providing ample space for customers to enjoy their meal without feeling cramped. The high ceilings and comfortable seating make it an ideal spot for groups or families to gather and indulge in some mouth-watering pizza.

I must add that Giordano's offers great value for its price. You won't have to break the bank to enjoy this excellent pizza! Moreover, the friendly service adds to the overall experience of dining at Giordano's.

If you're looking for a restaurant with outdoor seating, Giordano's has got you covered! It offers a comfortable outdoor seating area where you can bask in the sun while enjoying a slice or two of Chicago-style pizza.

In conclusion, if you're searching for one of Evanston's best pizzas, then look no further than Giordano's. With its delicious pizza, large dining area, great value for price, friendly service and comfortable outdoor seating area - it truly deserves its place among Evanston's top pizzerias.

You might also want to check out the best ribs in Schaumburg.