The Absolute Best Deep Dish Pizza in Elgin [Updated 2024]

Having evaluated a dozen of the finest offerings in town, I've tasted everything from classic cheese to innovative toppings that push the boundaries of this beloved dish.

Each pizza tells a unique story, reflecting not just ingredients but also the passion of the local chefs who create them.

In a city that prides itself on heartwarming comfort food, I've discovered hidden gems and crowd favorites that will satisfy any deep dish craving.

Join me on this mouthwatering journey as I reveal my top picks for deep dish pizza in Elgin, where each slice is a celebration of flavor and tradition.

Nick's Pizza & Pub

Highlights
Unique hunting lodge decor
Great service and friendly staff
Quick pizza preparation
Tasty wings and special pizza
Entertaining atmosphere

Nestled in a cozy corner of Elgin, Nick's Pizza & Pub greets visitors with a unique hunting lodge decor that instantly sets a whimsical, yet welcoming atmosphere. Upon entering, I was quickly charmed by the friendly staff whose great service truly made my experience delightful.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show: the deep dish pizza! While I was enticed by their extensive menu, I couldn't resist trying their special pizza, renowned for its generous toppings and oozing cheese. It arrived at my table in record time—kudos to their quick pizza preparation—perfectly baked with a crispy crust that held its shape as I dug in.

Paired with their tasty wings, this meal was an absolute treat. Each bite of that deep dish was a harmonious blend of flavors, making my taste buds sing with joy. The atmosphere buzzed with laughter and chatter, creating an entertaining experience that left a lasting impression.

Overall, Nick's Pizza & Pub has solidified its place in Elgin's deep dish scene, and I highly recommend it for anyone seeking an enjoyable meal in a vibrant setting. 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best deep dish pizza in Naperville.

White Cottage Pizzeria

Highlights
Strives for timely service
Fresh and tender calamari
Cheesy, meaty deep dish pizza
Excellent food quality
Great atmosphere

When entering White Cottage Pizzeria, you are immediately embraced by a warm and inviting atmosphere, a perfect prelude to the delicious journey that awaits. The waitstaff is not only friendly but also strives for timely service, ensuring your deep dish pizza will be in your hands before you can say “extra cheese!”

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show: their deep dish pizza. Cheese lovers, prepare yourselves! The moment the pizza lands on your table, your senses are assaulted with a hearty blend of melted cheese and savory toppings that dance in perfect harmony. As I took my first slice, the meaty goodness intertwined with the crispy crust sent me into a flavor frenzy. It was a delightful marriage of textures—crispy on the outside, tender on the inside.

But wait, there’s more! Their fresh and tender calamari served as a perfect starter, complementing the meal beautifully. The overall food quality here is excellent, and I found myself fully engaged in each bite. If you're in Elgin and craving a slice of deep dish joy, White Cottage Pizzeria is an experience not to be missed! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best deep dish pizza in Joliet.

Moretti's Elgin

Highlights
Spacious venue
Waterfront view
Good pasta and appetizers
Attentive server
Private event space

First off, the spacious venue was a pleasant surprise. I didn't feel like I was crammed into a tiny space like a sardine in a can. Plus, the waterfront view added to the overall ambiance.

Before diving into the main attraction, I decided to try some of their good pasta and appetizers. The garlic knots were so tasty that they almost stole the show from the deep dish pizza. Almost.

Speaking of which, the deep dish pizza was absolutely amazing! It had all of the right elements - crust, sauce, cheese and toppings -, all perfectly balanced together in every bite. As an expert reviewer, I can confidently say that Moretti's Elgin has one of the best deep dish pizzas in town.

What made my experience even better was our attentive server, who made sure we had everything we needed without being intrusive or overbearing.

If you're planning on having a private event, Moretti's Elgin also has a private event space available for rental.

Overall, Moretti's Elgin exceeded my expectations with their delicious deep dish pizza and excellent service. If you're in Elgin and craving some top-notch pizza, definitely give them a try!

You might also want to check out the best deep dish pizza in Oak Park.

Giordano's

Highlights
Excellent food
Friendly staff
Hot, fresh pizza
Delicious wings

First of all, I have to say that the food was excellent. The pizza was definitely the star of the show, with its thick crust and generous toppings. The cheese was melted to perfection and there was just the right amount of sauce.

The staff at Giordano's were also incredibly friendly and helpful. They made us feel welcome from the moment we walked in the door and were happy to answer any questions we had about their menu.

I was impressed by how hot and fresh our pizza was when it arrived at our table. It's clear that they take pride in making sure their pizzas are served at their best.

One thing I wasn't expecting was how delicious their wings were! They were perfectly seasoned and cooked just right. It's always nice when a restaurant can surprise you with something unexpected.

Overall, my experience at Giordano's in Elgin was fantastic. From the excellent food to the friendly staff, I would definitely recommend this place to anyone who is looking for a great deep dish pizza joint in Elgin.

You might also want to check out the best deep dish pizza in Schaumburg.

Chicago Pizza Authority

Highlights
Tavern-style pizza
Excellent thin crust pizza
Friendly and helpful staff
Plenty of parking available

To start, let me say that Chicago Pizza Authority is not your typical deep dish pizza joint. Instead, they specialize in tavern-style pizzas which are thin crust and cut into squares. I was skeptical at first, but boy was I pleasantly surprised! The crust was crispy and had the perfect amount of chewiness. The sauce was tangy and the cheese had a great melt to it. It's safe to say that their thin crust pizza is excellent!

But, I know what you're thinking - "What about the deep dish?" Well, unfortunately they don't offer a true "deep dish" option. However, they do have a thicker crust pizza called the "Chicago Thick" which is similar to a deep dish but not quite there. Don't get me wrong, it's still delicious and worth trying if you want something heartier than their thin crust.

The staff at Chicago Pizza Authority were incredibly friendly and helpful in explaining their menu options to me. They even gave me some great recommendations on what to try next time I visit.

Another plus? There's plenty of parking available in their lot which can be hard to come by in Elgin.

Overall, while Chicago Pizza Authority may not have traditional deep dish pizzas, their tavern-style thin crust pizzas are worth checking out. Plus, with excellent customer service and easy parking options, it's a win-win situation!

You might also want to check out the best deep dish pizza in Aurora.

Mel's Pizza

Highlights
Best deep dish
Family owned
Excellent work
Great service

First of all, I must say that Mel's Pizza has some of the best deep dish pizzas in Elgin. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. The cheese was melted to perfection, and the sauce had a great balance of tangy and sweet flavors.

But what really impressed me about Mel's Pizza was their family-owned atmosphere. You can feel the love and care put into every pizza they make. It's like being invited to dinner at your Italian friend's house - you know you're in for a treat.

The staff at Mel's Pizza also deserves recognition. They do an excellent job making sure that customers are happy with their meals. They were attentive, friendly, and made our visit feel like we were part of their family.

Lastly, I would like to mention that Mel's Pizza has great service overall. The staff made sure to answer any questions we had, and they even gave us recommendations for other places to visit in Elgin.

Overall, if you're looking for a delicious deep dish pizza with a warm family atmosphere and top-notch service, then I highly recommend visiting Mel's Pizza in Elgin!

You might also want to check out the best deep dish pizza in Evanston.

Lou Malnati's Pizzeria

Highlights
Amazing pizza
Frozen option available
Taste of Chicago at home

First of all, let me tell you that the pizza here is absolutely amazing! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by the savory aroma of cheese and tomato sauce. I ordered their classic deep dish pepperoni pizza and it did not disappoint. The crust was perfectly crispy and the cheese was melted to perfection. Each bite was a heavenly experience.

But what really sets Lou Malnati's Pizzeria apart is that they offer a frozen option, which means you can take a little taste of Chicago home with you! This is perfect for those who can't make it to Elgin frequently but still want to enjoy some delicious deep dish pizza.

Overall, my experience at Lou Malnati's Pizzeria was exceptional. The quality of their pizza truly speaks for itself. If you're in Elgin and looking for some authentic deep dish pizza, this is definitely the place to go. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you.

You might also want to check out the best tamales in Aurora.

Maciano's Pizza & Pastaria

Highlights
Delicious thin pizza
Authentic Italian food
Generous with toppings
Great service
Reasonably priced

The first thing that caught my attention was their delicious thin pizza. I know, I know. It's supposed to be a deep dish review, but trust me on this one. I couldn't resist trying it out and I wasn't disappointed. The crust was crispy and the toppings were fresh and vibrant.

But let's talk about the deep dish pizza now, shall we? Maciano's definitely knows how to create an authentic Italian experience with their deep dish pizzas. The sauce was rich and flavorful, the cheese was gooey and melted to perfection, and they were generous with toppings! Each bite was like a journey through a flavor wonderland.

I must also commend them for their great service. The staff was friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about their menu. They even gave me some suggestions on what other dishes to try next time.

And you know what's even better? All of this comes at a reasonably priced tag! Quality food without breaking the bank? Yes please!

Overall, if you're looking for a delicious deep dish pizza in Elgin with authentic Italian flavors, Maciano's Pizza & Pastaria is definitely worth checking out!

You might also want to check out the best thai food in Schaumburg.

Geno Nottolini's Pizza & Catering Company

Highlights
Delicious catering for large groups
Friendly and helpful delivery staff
Great food with large portions
High-quality pizza
Convenient parking in the back

First of all, if you're looking for a place to feed a crowd, Geno Nottolini's is the perfect choice. Their catering services are top-notch and can satisfy any group size. Plus, their delivery staff is incredibly friendly and helpful, making the process stress-free.

Now let's talk about the stars of the show - their deep dish pizzas. I have to say, they did not disappoint! The pizzas were cooked to perfection with plenty of cheese and toppings. What impressed me most was the quality of ingredients used - it really made a difference in the taste. And don't worry about going hungry because these pizzas come in large portions.

What I appreciated about Geno Nottolini's was their attention to detail. They take pride in their pizza-making craft and it shows in every bite. Also, parking can be a hassle in some parts of Elgin but this place has convenient parking in the back which makes it easy to access.

Overall, if you're on the hunt for delicious deep dish pizza, Geno Nottolini's Pizza & Catering Company should definitely be on your list of places to try!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Schaumburg.

Rosati's Pizza

Highlights
Great thin crust
Delicious
Still great after years
Satisfying portions

First of all, let me just say that their thin crust pizza was a delightful surprise. It had the perfect amount of crunch and chewiness, making it an excellent choice for those who prefer a lighter option. However, that doesn't mean their deep dish pizzas were any less impressive!

I tried their classic deep dish pizza and boy, was it delicious! The sauce was tangy with just the right amount of sweetness, and the cheese was perfectly melted on top. I loved how each slice had a generous amount of toppings which gave it a satisfying taste.

What's even better is that their quality hasn't changed over the years. Rosati's Pizza is still as good as it was when I first visited them years ago. They truly know how to make a great pizza that's worth coming back for.

The portions are also very satisfying so you won't leave feeling hungry. Plus, their prices are reasonable which makes it a great value for your money.

Overall, if you're looking for some amazing deep dish pizza in Elgin, then Rosati's Pizza should definitely be on your list. Their great thin crust and signature deep dish pizzas are simply irresistible!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Naperville.

Taylor Street Pizza

Highlights
Fresh slices ready
Friendly prompt staff
Convenient location
Generous slice size
Varied menu options

First and foremost, I was pleased to find that they had fresh slices of deep dish pizza already waiting for me. No need to wait for it to be made from scratch! The staff was also incredibly friendly and prompt, which is always appreciated when you're hungry and craving some delicious pizza.

The location itself is quite convenient, making it an easy choice for a quick lunch or dinner. And let's talk about the slice size - generous would be an understatement! It was a hearty slice that left me feeling satisfied.

What sets Taylor Street Pizza apart from other deep dish places in Elgin is their varied menu options. Sure, they have your classic pepperoni and sausage toppings, but they also offer unique options like chicken bacon ranch and veggie lovers. As someone who likes to mix things up, this was a huge plus for me!

Overall, I highly recommend giving Taylor Street Pizza a try if you're in the mood for some top-quality deep dish pizza in Elgin. With fresh slices ready, friendly staff, convenient location, generous slice size, and varied menu options, it's definitely one of the best options around town.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in Elgin.

MOD Pizza

Highlights
Friendly staff
Unlimited toppings
Quick service
Delicious and accurate pizzas
Hot honey drizzle

Upon entering the restaurant, I was greeted by the friendly staff who helped me choose my toppings and directed me towards the ordering station. The best part of MOD Pizza is that they offer unlimited toppings, which means I could go all out on my pizza without any extra charges.

The service was quick, and within minutes, my pizza was ready. As soon as I took a bite of my deep dish pizza, I knew this was going to be one of the best pizzas I have ever had. The crust was perfectly thick and crispy, while the sauce had just the right amount of tanginess to it.

What impressed me most about MOD Pizza was their attention to detail. They made sure that every topping was placed accurately on the pizza, and nothing fell off while eating it. It's safe to say that my experience at this restaurant has set a new standard for all other pizzerias in Elgin.

One unique aspect of MOD Pizza is their hot honey drizzle, which added an extra kick of flavor to my already amazing pizza. Trust me when I say that this drizzle is not something you want to miss out on!

Overall, if you're looking for a delicious deep dish pizza with unlimited toppings and excellent service, MOD Pizza in Elgin is definitely worth checking out!

You might also want to check out the best steak in Schaumburg.