The Absolute Best Cake in Evanston [Updated 2024]

Over the years, I've sampled countless slices from bakeries all around town, each with its unique flair and flavors.

After reviewing twelve standout contenders, I've compiled a list that celebrates creativity, texture, and of course, taste.

From classic chocolate to innovative vegan options, Evanston's cake scene is as diverse as its residents.

Join me as I take you on a delicious journey through the top picks that are sure to make any occasion special!

Beth's Little Bake Shop

Highlights
Stunning custom cake designs
Delicious baked goodies
Big flavor in little macarons
Beautifully decorated desserts
Artistic cake decorator

Beth's Little Bake Shop is a delightful find in the heart of Evanston, where every visit feels like stepping into a sugary wonderland. As soon as I entered, I was greeted by the stunning display of custom cake designs that not only look like pieces of art but also invite you to take a slice of joy.

I opted for a classic vanilla cake adorned with delicate buttercream flowers. The first bite was enough to transport me to a world of flavors — the cake was moist and fluffy, with the perfect balance of sweetness. Each mouthful was a celebration of texture and taste that kept me coming back for more. And let’s not overlook the little macarons that surprisingly pack a big flavor—these tiny treats were delightful bursts of almond and fruit that left me wanting to explore the entire selection.

The atmosphere is as charming as the baked goods, making it an artistic haven for anyone with a sweet tooth. If you find yourself in Evanston, Beth's Little Bake Shop will undoubtedly have you falling in love with cake all over again. You won’t just be savoring cake; you’ll be experiencing a masterpiece! 🍰✨

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Schaumburg.

Bennison's Bakery

Highlights
Classic Evanston tradition
Friendly and kind staff
Delicious donuts and pastries
Charming outdoor patio
Nostalgic childhood favorite

Visiting Bennison's Bakery in Evanston is like stepping into a delightful slice of nostalgia. This charming bakery is a staple in the community, and as I entered, I was greeted by the friendly and kind staff who immediately made me feel at home. The aroma of freshly baked goods wrapped around me like a warm hug, setting the perfect atmosphere for what was to come.

While I was tempted by their delicious donuts and pastries, my focus today was on the cake, which did not disappoint. I opted for their classic vanilla layer cake, and let me tell you, it was nothing short of perfection! The layers were moist and fluffy, while the frosting was a heavenly blend—sweet yet light, leaving me wanting just one more slice.

Sipping my coffee on their charming outdoor patio, I couldn't help but reflect on the joy this place brings to the community. Bennison's isn’t just a bakery; it’s a cherished Evanston tradition that continues to delight locals and newcomers alike. If you haven’t visited yet, you’re missing out on a piece of delicious history! 🍰

You might also want to check out the best mexican seafood restaurants in Chicago.

Great Harvest Bread Co. Evanston

Highlights
Fresh breads
Delicious coffee
Friendly service

First of all, can we take a moment to appreciate the aroma of freshly baked bread that hits you as soon as you step inside? It's heavenly! But enough about the bread, let's talk cake. The first thing I noticed was their display of cakes - they looked absolutely stunning!

I decided to try their chocolate cake and it did not disappoint. The cake was moist and had a rich flavor that wasn't too overwhelming. The frosting was perfectly balanced with the cake and wasn't overly sweet like some chocolate frostings can be.

But what really stood out to me was their attention to detail in presentation. Each slice was beautifully decorated with a drizzle of chocolate and a sprinkle of cocoa powder on top. It made me feel like I was indulging in something truly special.

To accompany my cake, I ordered a cup of coffee which was equally delicious. They use locally roasted beans and the barista knew her craft well, creating beautiful latte art on top.

Lastly, I have to give a shoutout to the friendly staff who were welcoming and helpful throughout my visit.

Overall, Great Harvest Bread Co. Evanston is definitely worth checking out for their fresh breads, delicious coffee and beautiful cakes. It's no wonder they have such a loyal following in Evanston!

You might also want to check out the best tamales in Aurora.

Pâtisserie Coralie

Highlights
Delicious pastries
Authentic Parisian feel
Quiche and croissants are amazing

First of all, let me just say that this place has an authentic Parisian feel to it. From the decor to the pastries, everything is just so French. It's like being transported to a charming little café in Paris.

Now, let's get down to business: the cakes. Oh boy, where do I even begin? The cakes at Pâtisserie Coralie are simply divine. They're moist, flavorful, and perfectly balanced. Each bite is like a little piece of heaven in your mouth.

But wait, there's more! The croissants and quiche are also amazing. They're flaky, buttery, and oh-so-satisfying. You can tell that they're made with love and care.

Overall, I highly recommend Pâtisserie Coralie for anyone looking for the best cake in Evanston. Whether you're in the mood for a sweet treat or a savory snack, this place has got you covered. And hey, if you can't make it to Paris anytime soon, this is definitely the next best thing!

You might also want to check out the best thai food in Schaumburg.

Cinnaholic

Highlights
Best cinnamon buns in the city
Delicious and amazing selection
Top-notch customer service

I have to say, Cinnaholic has the best cinnamon buns in the city! From their classic flavors like cinnamon and sugar to unique creations like cookie dough and s'mores, their selection is amazing. Their buns are incredibly soft and gooey with just the right amount of sweetness. And don't even get me started on their frosting options - I could eat it straight out of the container!

But what really sets Cinnaholic apart is their top-notch customer service. The staff is incredibly friendly and welcoming. They take the time to explain all of their flavors and even let you sample as many as you want (which can be dangerous because they're all so delicious!). Plus, they're always willing to customize your order to fit your preferences.

Overall, if you're looking for a sweet treat that will satisfy your cravings, look no further than Cinnaholic in Evanston. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Schaumburg.

Hewn

Highlights
Naturally fermented sourdough bread
Bread variety changes daily
Excellent quality bread
Skilled bakers

While Hewn is known for their naturally fermented sourdough bread, I couldn't help but try their cakes! The bread variety changes daily, so I wasn't sure what to expect when it came to the cakes. However, I was pleasantly surprised by the excellent quality of the cake.

The skilled bakers at Hewn really know their way around pastries and desserts. The cake was moist and fluffy with just the right amount of sweetness. The frosting was heavenly and didn't overpower the cake itself. It was clear that every ingredient used was carefully selected and blended together perfectly.

I couldn't resist trying more than one slice, but my personal favorite had to be the chocolate cake with vanilla frosting. It was like a party in my mouth! Every bite was a burst of joy and happiness. And believe me, after tasting it, you won't think twice about how many calories are in it.

Overall, if you're looking for an exquisite cake experience in Evanston, don't miss out on Hewn! They definitely have some of the best cakes in town (even though they're primarily known for their bread).

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Naperville.

Leonidas Cafe Chocolaterie

Highlights
Delicious crepes and pastries
Best French bakery in Evanston
Supreme hot chocolate
Amazing breakfast crepes
Great coffee and chocolate

Firstly, let me just say that their crepes and pastries were absolutely divine! I tried their breakfast crepes and I was blown away by the flavors. The sweetness of the fruit combined with the savory eggs and cheese was a perfect match.

The highlight of my visit to Leonidas Cafe Chocolaterie was their supreme hot chocolate. It was so rich and decadent that I felt like I was in Paris sipping on some hot cocoa in a cozy cafe.

Now let's talk about their cakes - they were out of this world! The texture of the cake was soft and moist, while the frosting was light yet flavorful. It's no surprise that Leonidas Cafe Chocolaterie is considered as the best French bakery in Evanston.

To top it off, they have great coffee and chocolate, which made my visit even more enjoyable. Their coffee had a nice aroma and tasted bold yet smooth.

Overall, I would highly recommend Leonidas Cafe Chocolaterie for anyone who is looking for an authentic French pastry experience. With its delicious crepes, amazing cakes, supreme hot chocolate, great coffee, and chocolate, you'll be sure to leave with a smile on your face.

You might also want to check out the best tacos in Elgin.

JR Dessert Bakery

Highlights
Edible Decorations
Easy Ordering Process
Moist and Delicious Cake
Amazing Cream Cheese Frosting

First of all, let me say that the ordering process was a breeze. I didn't have to jump through any hoops or sign up for an account just to order a cake. It was as easy as pie (or should I say cake?).

Now, let's talk about the cake itself. Oh my goodness, it was so moist and delicious! The texture was perfect - not too dense, not too fluffy - just right. And the cream cheese frosting...wow. I could've eaten that by the spoonful.

But what really impressed me were the edible decorations on top of the cake. They were so intricate and detailed, it was almost a shame to eat them...almost.

Overall, I highly recommend JR Dessert Bakery for anyone looking for a tasty and visually appealing cake in Evanston. And if you're anything like me, you'll be dreaming about that cream cheese frosting for days afterwards.

You might also want to check out the best steak in Schaumburg.

Cupitol Coffee & Eatery

Highlights
Delicious food and drinks
Fast service
Lovely, cozy atmosphere
Must-try pistachio croissant

From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a lovely, cozy atmosphere that made me feel right at home. The staff were incredibly friendly and offered fast service, which is always appreciated when you're eager to indulge in some delicious treats.

Speaking of treats, let's talk about their cakes! Although they have a variety of options, I decided to try their chocolate cake and boy was it worth it. The cake was moist and rich with just the right amount of sweetness. It was beautifully presented with a dollop of whipped cream on top and just the right amount of chocolate shavings.

But if you're looking for something a little different, then trust me and try their pistachio croissant. It's flaky and buttery with a creamy pistachio filling that will leave you wanting more.

Overall, Cupitol Coffee & Eatery is definitely worth visiting whether you're in the mood for coffee or tea or looking for a sweet treat. With their delicious food and drinks, fast service, and lovely atmosphere, it's clear why they are one of the best cafes in Evanston.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Evanston.

Sweet Temptations Bake Shop

Highlights
Best cake ever
Reasonable prices
Great customer service
Beautiful and tasty cakes
Customizable options

First of all, let me tell you that this place has the best cake ever! I had their chocolate fudge cake and it was so moist and rich in flavor that I couldn't resist taking a second bite. The cake was perfectly baked and decorated with beautiful frosting, making it almost too pretty to eat.

Another great thing about Sweet Temptations Bake Shop is that their prices are very reasonable. You can get a slice of heaven for just a few bucks, which is definitely worth it considering the quality and taste of their cakes.

The customer service at this bakery is also top-notch. The staff was very friendly and knowledgeable about their products. They even helped me customize my cake order to fit my preferences.

Speaking of customization, Sweet Temptations Bake Shop offers a variety of customizable options for their cakes. Whether you need a special message or want to add some unique decorations, they've got you covered!

Overall, I highly recommend Sweet Temptations Bake Shop for anyone looking for a delicious and beautifully crafted cake in Evanston. It's the perfect place for any occasion or even just as a treat for yourself!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Schaumburg.

Tag's Bakery

Highlights
Best pastries and cakes
Delicious everything
Great for events and gatherings

From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with the sweet aroma of freshly baked pastries and cakes. The display case was filled with an array of treats that looked almost too good to eat. Almost.

I decided to try their signature cake, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint. The layers were moist and perfectly balanced with just the right amount of sweetness. The frosting was velvety smooth and melted in my mouth like butter.

But Tag's Bakery isn't just about cakes - they have a wide variety of pastries that are equally delicious. From croissants to muffins, everything was top-notch.

And if you're looking for a place to host an event or gathering, Tag's Bakery is a great choice. Their staff is friendly and accommodating, making sure every detail is taken care of.

Overall, I can confidently say that Tag's Bakery has earned its spot on the list of best cakes in Evanston. With its delicious everything and impeccable service, it's definitely worth a visit.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Naperville.

Noir d’Ébène Chocolat et Pâtisserie

Highlights
Handmade chocolates
New Orleans-style beignets
Kindness of the owner
Pleasurable selection of sweets

Firstly, I was blown away by the handmade chocolates offered at Noir d’Ébène. The quality of the chocolate was superb and the flavors were simply divine. I highly recommend trying their dark chocolate truffles with sea salt.

Next, I tried their New Orleans-style beignets and was pleasantly surprised by how light and fluffy they were. They were not greasy at all and had just the right amount of sweetness.

What really stood out to me was the kindness of the owner, who took time to explain each dessert on display and even gave me personalized recommendations based on my taste preferences. It's always refreshing to see such genuine hospitality in a business.

Lastly, the selection of sweets available at Noir d’Ébène is truly pleasurable. From their macarons to their tarts, everything looked so delicious that it was hard to decide what to try next!

Overall, my experience at Noir d’Ébène Chocolat et Pâtisserie was nothing short of delightful. If you're looking for a place that offers outstanding handmade chocolates, heavenly beignets, and warm customer service, then this is definitely a must-visit spot in Evanston!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Schaumburg.